top of page

What Happens When a Condo Owner Causes Damage? Understanding Chargebacks Before You Join the Board

Hand writing on a chart report beside a calculator, with a white city-and-house logo in the top right and a focused mood.

A bathtub overflows in one unit and water reaches several floors below. Repairs are expensive, the corporation has a large insurance deductible and residents want to know who will pay. For someone thinking about joining a condo board, situations like this show why the role involves more than approving budgets and discussing building maintenance. Directors may also need to understand insurance, governing documents and the evidence behind a potential condo owner chargeback.


Where the Damage Started Is Only the Beginning


An overflowing bathtub can cause significant damage, but the owner of the source unit should automatically be billed for the corporation's insurance deductible. Directors need to work through several questions first. Is the loss covered by the corporation’s insurance? What does the standard unit bylaw say? What does the insurance deductible bylaw require? Is there evidence supporting owner responsibility?


Ontario law provides the framework. Under section 105 of the Condominium Act, 1998, the corporation’s deductible is generally a common expense. The section also establishes circumstances where the lesser of the repair cost and insurance deductible can be added to the common expenses payable for a particular unit. Corporations may also have deductible bylaws extending the circumstances in which this responsibility applies.


A Chargeback Needs a Legal and Factual Basis


The Condominium Authority of Ontario’s chargeback guidance explains that corporations can charge certain costs back to an owner through common expenses when permitted by the Act or the corporation’s governing documents. This prevents costs properly attributable to one owner from automatically being passed to everyone else. The CAO also recommends clear communication, references to the applicable provisions and detailed documentation before a chargeback is imposed.


Evidence becomes particularly important when responsibility depends on an act or omission. For example, knowing that water escaped from the machine establishes the source, but it may not prove that the owner failed to maintain it or ignored a known problem. A contractor’s report, maintenance history, photographs or other records may be needed before the board can confidently determine what happened.


Board Decisions Can Have Significant Financial Consequences


Three colleagues review financial charts at a desk, one pointing with a pencil in a bright office, focused and serious.

This is one reason prospective directors should understand what board service can involve. A condo owner chargeback may affect thousands of dollars and can eventually lead to a dispute if the owner disagrees with the corporation’s decision. The CAO notes that disputes involving repair and damage chargebacks generally fall outside the Condominium Authority Tribunal’s jurisdiction and may instead proceed through other dispute-resolution processes or Superior Court.


Directors are not expected to make complicated insurance or legal determinations alone. Their responsibility is to ask the right questions, review the corporation’s documents and involve the property manager, insurer or legal counsel when necessary.


Good Directors Do Not Rush the Answer


Joining a condo board means occasionally dealing with situations where the answer is not immediately obvious. When property damage occurs, a careful board looks beyond where the water came from and examines insurance coverage, the standard unit definition, deductible provisions and supporting evidence before deciding who should pay.


Understanding that process before joining the board can make the responsibility less intimidating. It also shows why good condominium governance depends on informed decisions rather than assumptions. City Sites Property Management can support boards in coordinating the operational and communication steps that follow when property damage affects a condominium community.


Listen to the podcast and learn more: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio 

Comments


bottom of page