Why Condo Boards Need Evidence Before Charging an Owner Back

A leak comes from a washing machine and water damages the unit below. The source seems obvious, so the owner should receive the bill, right? Not necessarily. For an Ontario condo board, identifying where damage originated is only one part of the process. Before issuing a condo chargeback, the corporation needs to establish the legal authority for the charge and document the facts supporting it.
A Source Is Not the Same as Proof
If a corporation’s insurance deductible provisions depend on an owner’s act or omission, knowing that water came from the washing machine does not automatically establish what the owner did wrong. The board may need evidence showing that the appliance had a known problem, maintenance was neglected or another action or failure contributed to the loss.
That evidence could include an incident report, photographs, contractor findings, maintenance records, correspondence with the owner or an inspection report. The exact evidence needed depends on the circumstances and the corporation’s governing documents. The important point is that the board should be able to explain how it reached its conclusion rather than working backwards from the location where the problem started.
Ontario Law Sets Limits on Chargebacks
The Condominium Authority of Ontario’s guidance on chargebacks explains that corporations can only charge costs back in circumstances authorized by the Condominium Act, 1998 or the corporation’s governing documents. The CAO also recommends documenting communications and the steps taken with an owner before a chargeback is imposed.

Damage and insurance deductibles have their own requirements. Section 105 of Ontario’s Condominium Act, 1998 addresses circumstances in which an amount related to an insurance deductible can be added to the common expenses payable for an owner’s unit. Corporations may also have bylaws extending deductible responsibility, so directors need to read the actual wording that applies to their building.
Recent Ontario disputes also show why documentation cannot be treated casually.
In Merrifield v. Russel et al., 2025 CanLII 6237, the Small Claims Court found, among other things, inadequate proof that the owner had violated the corporation’s governing documents. The case involved compliance-related legal costs rather than a water-damage deductible, so it is not a direct comparison to every chargeback situation. Still, it illustrates the risk of demanding payment when the factual and legal foundation has not been properly established.
Build the File Before Sending the Bill
A board should be able to answer several questions before issuing a chargeback: What happened? What evidence supports that conclusion? Which provision of the Act, declaration or bylaw authorizes the charge? How was the amount calculated?
The goal is not to create unnecessary paperwork. It is to make sure a potentially significant financial decision can be supported if the owner challenges it. A well-documented file also gives the property manager, insurer and legal counsel better information when the situation becomes complicated.
For boards working through damage claims and other operational issues, City Sites Property Management can help keep documentation, communication and condominium management processes organized before a disagreement becomes harder to resolve.
Listen to the podcast and learn more: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio





Comments