top of page

Is Your Condo's Insurance Deductible Bylaw Ready Before the Next Water Leak?

A major water leak is not the time for a condo board to discover that nobody is quite sure what its insurance deductible bylaw says. Once water has damaged several units and the corporation is facing a significant deductible, the question of who pays can quickly become contentious. For current directors, reviewing the condo insurance deductible bylaw before a loss happens can make the response much clearer.


The Act Is Only the Starting Point


Hand holds shield with red check mark beside leaking copper pipe spraying water; white home icon in corner.

Under section 105 of Ontario’s Condominium Act, 1998, the corporation’s insurance deductible is generally a common expense. The Act also provides circumstances in which an amount can be added to the common expenses of a particular unit when damage results from an owner’s, resident’s or guest’s act or omission. Importantly, the Act allows condominium corporations to pass a bylaw extending the circumstances in which an owner may be responsible for the deductible.


This is why two Ontario condos experiencing very similar leaks can face different outcomes. Their deductible bylaws may not say the same thing.


A bylaw may require an act or omission connecting an owner’s conduct to the damage, while another corporation may have broader wording permitted under section 105 (3). In practical terms, one corporation may need evidence connecting an owner’s conduct to the damage, while another may have broader wording that applies based on the circumstances set out in its bylaw.


The Exact Wording Matters


Ontario courts have considered what “act or omission” means in deductible disputes. In Lozano v. Toronto Standard Condominium Corporation No. 1765, 2020 ONSC 4583, later addressed on appeal, the dispute arose after a water leak occurred while the owners were away for an extended period. The case became important for interpreting the causal connection required between an owner’s act or omission and the resulting damage. A legal analysis of the Lozano decisions explains that establishing an act or omission does not necessarily require proving negligence, but there must be the required causal link between the conduct and damage.


The distinction becomes especially important when a corporation has adopted a broader deductible bylaw. Canadian Condominium Institute Toronto explains that section 105(3) permits a properly drafted bylaw to extend deductible responsibility beyond the Act’s default circumstances, including provisions that may remove the requirement to establish an owner’s act or omission.


Review the Bylaw Before the Claim


Business team meeting through glass in a bright office, reviewing documents and a tablet at a table.

Boards should therefore know what their condo insurance deductible bylaw actually requires. Does it depend on an act or omission? Has responsibility been extended based on where the damage originated? Does the wording reflect the corporation’s current insurance arrangements? Those questions are much easier to address during a governance review than while residents are waiting for repairs and invoices are arriving.


Governing documents should be reviewed before they are needed. A board may discover that its existing bylaw works perfectly well, or legal and insurance professionals may identify wording that deserves another look.


Directors should also make sure owners receive current information about the corporation’s deductible so they can discuss appropriate coverage with their own insurers. For boards that need help coordinating insurance information, governing documents and day-to-day building operations, City Sites Property Management can help keep those responsibilities organized before the next incident tests them.


Listen to the podcast and learn more: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio 


Comments


bottom of page