top of page

Your Condo Has a Rule, But Can You Actually Enforce It?

Broken hourglass resting on a wooden gavel against a pink background, symbolizing time and legal decisions.

A sign in the party room says no outside alcohol. A move-in form sets a restriction on elevator use. A board policy tells residents what they cannot do in a common area. These instructions may look official, but that does not automatically make them enforceable condo rules. For current directors, effective condo rule enforcement starts with a more basic question: where does the requirement actually come from?


A Rule Has to Meet Ontario's Requirements


Under section 58 of Ontario’s Condominium Act, 1998, boards can make rules to promote the safety, security or welfare of owners and the property, or to prevent unreasonable interference with the use and enjoyment of units and common elements. Rules must also be reasonable and consistent with the Act, declaration and bylaws.


The Condominium Authority of Ontario’s guidance on condo rules gives examples such as regulating parking, pets, amenity access and short-term rentals. A board can pass or amend a rule, but owners must receive the required notice and have an opportunity to requisition a meeting.


Once properly in effect, rules are not optional. Section 58(10) says people bound by them must comply, while sections 17(3) and 119 establish broader obligations concerning enforcement and compliance with the corporation’s governing documents.


A Sign or Policy Is Not Automatically a Rule


Problems arise when the corporation tries to enforce something that was never properly included in its governing documents. A sign may communicate expectations, but directors should not assume that posting it creates an enforceable rule. Important restrictions may need to appear in the corporation’s rules or, depending on the circumstances, in a properly structured agreement residents sign when booking an amenity.


Close-up of hands signing a document with a pen at a desk, focused and professional.

Policies require similar care. The CAO confirms that policies are not governing documents and cannot impose restrictions beyond those found in the declaration, bylaws and rules. Ontario tribunal decisions have demonstrated the consequences. In Tartakovsky-Guilels v. York Region Condominium Corporation No. 829, 2024 ONCAT 152 and Boodram v. Peel Standard Condominium Corporation No. 843, 2021 ONCAT 31, the CAT found policies that were effectively improperly implemented rules and therefore unenforceable.


Audit Before Enforcement Becomes Necessary


Boards can avoid many disputes by reviewing their rules, policies, signs, forms and amenity agreements together. If a restriction appears only on a sign or in an internal policy, directors should determine whether the corporation has proper authority to enforce it before sending compliance letters.


Where a valid rule is being breached, the CAO outlines an escalating enforcement process that can begin with notifying the resident and progress, when necessary, to legal counsel, the Condominium Authority Tribunal, mediation, arbitration or Superior Court depending on the dispute.


Good condo rule enforcement therefore begins well before a violation occurs. Boards need clear documents that were created through the proper process and accurately reflect what the corporation intends to regulate. City Sites Property Management can help boards keep rules, resident communications and day-to-day management practices aligned before an enforcement issue turns into a larger dispute.


Listen to the podcast and learn more: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio 


Comments


bottom of page