Rules, Bylaws or Policies? How Condo Boards Should Tell the Difference

A condo board wants to solve a problem, so it creates a policy. It sounds straightforward, but there is an important question directors should ask first: is a policy actually the right tool? In Ontario condominiums, rules, bylaws and policies serve different purposes, and confusing them can create problems when the corporation later tries to enforce a requirement. Understanding condo rules, bylaws and policies helps new directors know what the board can create, what requires owner involvement and what can actually be enforced.
Bylaws Govern How the Corporation Operates
The Condominium Authority of Ontario (CAO) describes bylaws as administrative guidelines that generally focus on governance and how a condominium board carries out its duties. They can address matters such as board composition, voting procedures, financial matters and the definition of a standard unit. A board can pass, amend or repeal a bylaw, but owner approval is required and an approved bylaw must be registered with the Land Registry Office before becoming effective.
Rules Regulate Day-to-Day Condo Living
Rules have a different purpose. Section 58 of Ontario’s Condominium Act, 1998 allows boards to make rules concerning units and common elements to promote safety, security or welfare, or prevent unreasonable interference with their use and enjoyment. Rules must also be reasonable and consistent with the Act, declaration and bylaws.
This is where matters such as parking, amenity use, pets or smoking may arise. The board can make a rule, but owners must receive formal notice and have an opportunity to requisition an owners’ meeting before it takes effect. Unlike bylaws, rules do not have to be registered on title.
The CSPM podcast makes the same distinction, emphasizing that rules are part of the corporation’s enforceable governing framework rather than simply an internal board procedure.
A Policy Is Not Another Kind of Rule

Policies are where boards can run into trouble. Policies can serve as internal guides for the corporation and board, covering areas such as privacy, video surveillance, customer service and workplace violence and harassment policies.
A policy should not automatically be treated as creating an enforceable obligation against owners.
The CAO similarly states that policies are not governing documents. They can support daily operations or explain how the corporation will handle particular situations, but they cannot independently impose restrictions that should properly appear in the declaration, bylaws or rules.
There are Ontario tribunal decisions showing why this distinction matters. The CAO points to cases including Tartakovsky-Guilels v. York Region Condominium Corporation No. 829, 2024 ONCAT 152, and Boodram v. Peel Standard Condominium Corporation No. 843, 2021 ONCAT 31, as examples where policies were found to be improperly implemented rules and were not enforceable.
Choose the Document Before Trying to Enforce It
Before approving a new restriction, sign, form or policy, a condo board should ask what it is actually trying to accomplish. Is it governing corporate administration? Regulating resident behaviour? Or simply documenting an internal procedure? That answer helps determine whether the corporation needs a bylaw, rule or policy.
Getting that distinction right at the beginning can prevent confusion when enforcement becomes necessary later. For condominium boards that need support connecting governance requirements with day-to-day operations, City Sites Property Management can help boards build clearer and more consistent management processes.
Listen to the podcast and learn more: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio





Comments