top of page

When the Same Vendor Has Been Used for Years, Is It Time to Test the Market?

Nov 17, 2024
2 min read
Businessman in black suit checks wristwatch against a red background with a white city-and-house icon, suggesting real estate business.

Long-standing vendor relationships are not automatically a problem. A contractor that knows the property, understands its equipment and has consistently delivered strong service can provide real operational value. The concern begins when familiar condo vendor contracts renew year after year without anyone checking whether the pricing, scope or service still reflects current market conditions. Testing the market does not mean the existing contractor must be replaced.


Familiarity Has Value, but So Does Competition

Changing contractors can create transition risk, particularly when the incumbent has years of knowledge about the property. A new vendor may need time to understand equipment history, access procedures and recurring issues. That history should be part of the evaluation. At the same time, familiarity should not become a reason to stop looking at the market altogether.


Pricing, labour conditions and service options change over time. A contract that represented excellent value five years ago may still be competitive, but the board cannot confirm that without current information. Vendor complacency can develop when the same companies continue receiving work simply because the relationship is established. A periodic market test provides information without presuming wrongdoing.


Start Before the Renewal Deadline

Contract visibility becomes especially important when renewal or termination notice periods are involved. If directors first reconsider a service agreement days before automatic renewal, their practical options may already be limited. The CAO’s procurement guide recommends documenting contractual obligations and tracking contract renewal and termination dates. That gives management enough time to review performance, update the scope and obtain competitive proposals if appropriate.


Hand selecting a highlighted business profile icon from a row of blue user icons on a blue background.

Testing the market also does not mean choosing the cheapest competitor. The incumbent vendor should be evaluated on service history, response times, reliability and price against the alternatives. A lower proposal that excludes emergency coverage or reduces service frequency may not provide the same value. Directors need comparable scopes before drawing conclusions.



Test the Assumption, Not the Relationship

A healthy procurement process should be capable of confirming that a long-standing vendor remains a good choice. City Sites’ vendor-management program describes access to thousands of vendors and the ability to obtain multiple quotes, demonstrating how technology can make market testing less administratively burdensome. The question for the board is therefore not “Have we used this company for too long?” It is “When did we last confirm that the service, scope and pricing still make sense for this corporation?”



Listen to the podcast and learn more: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio 

bottom of page