top of page

What to Do When Your Board Loses Confidence in Its Project Consultant

May 20, 2024
3 min read

“I don’t trust the consultant anymore” describes a feeling, not necessarily the underlying problem. Directors should identify what happened to create that concern.


Perhaps the project has experienced repeated change orders. Maybe the consultant recommended work the board does not understand, or invoices are being certified when directors believe progress is insufficient. The issue could also be poor communication, delayed reports or disagreement about the interpretation of the project specifications. Writing down the specific concerns changes the discussion. It allows the board to ask for explanations and creates a clearer question for another professional if independent advice becomes necessary.


Understand the Consultant’s Contractual Role 

Before concluding that the consultant has exceeded or failed in its responsibilities, directors should review what the consultant was actually retained to do. The consultant agreement may cover investigation, design, tendering, contract administration, site reviews, payment certification or other defined services.


Businessman in black suit holds clipboard and pen at desk, with a white city logo on a bright red background.

On a project using CCDC 2, the Canadian Construction Documents Committee identifies the consultant’s role and authority as part of the standard contract framework. That role interacts with the construction contract, but the consultant’s own professional-services agreement also matters. A board may expect continuous site supervision when the engagement provides only periodic field review. Conversely, directors may discover that reports or services required by the agreement have not been provided. The contract gives the discussion a factual starting point.


Consider Independent Technical Advice

A peer review can be useful when the board has a genuine technical question but is not yet ready to replace the project team. Another qualified professional can be retained to examine a defined issue, such as the proposed repair methodology, a disputed recommendation or the apparent extent of deterioration.


Independent advice should not become an informal attempt to have two consultants administer the same project simultaneously. The scope of the review needs to be clear. The board should understand what the second professional is being asked to assess and how the resulting opinion will be used.


This approach also fits the governance framework under section 37 of Ontario’s Condominium Act, 1998, which addresses directors’ good-faith reliance on reports or opinions from qualified professionals.


Replacing a Consultant Has Consequences

Sometimes replacement is necessary. A complete breakdown in the relationship, serious performance concerns or another significant issue may make continuing impractical. But changing consultants in the middle of construction is not the same as changing landscapers at the end of a season.


The incoming professional needs to understand the existing design, construction status, changes, deficiencies and project records. The corporation must also review the existing consultant agreement for termination requirements and determine how responsibilities will transition. Legal advice may be appropriate before the corporation terminates a significant professional-services agreement.


There may also be additional costs and delays. Those consequences do not mean the board should keep an unsuitable consultant. They mean the decision should be based on a clear comparison between the problems associated with staying and the risks associated with changing.


Restore Facts to the Centre of the Discussion

Capital projects are stressful because directors are responsible for large expenditures involving technical issues they may never have encountered before. When confidence starts to disappear, the board benefits from slowing the decision down enough to identify the actual concern.


Ask for the consultant’s explanation. Review the engagement. Examine the project records. If the technical issue remains unresolved, consider appropriately scoped independent advice. Then decide whether the relationship can be repaired or replacement is justified.


The CAO’s procurement guidance emphasizes documenting needs, evaluating professional services carefully and monitoring contractual obligations after procurement. Those principles remain relevant long after the consultant has been hired.


City Sites Property Management can help boards keep project communication, documentation and administrative coordination organized while technical and legal professionals provide the specialized advice required for major capital work.


Comments


bottom of page