Why Calling Someone an Independent Contractor Does Not Make Them One

A condominium corporation may hire someone, issue payments against invoices and describe that person in an agreement as an independent contractor. That wording can make the arrangement appear straightforward. Under Ontario employment law, however, the label used by the parties is not necessarily what determines the worker’s legal status. For new directors, understanding the difference between an independent contractor vs employee in Ontario matters because getting it wrong can expose the corporation to obligations it did not expect.
The Working Relationship Matters
Ontario’s Employment Standards Act guidance makes the principle clear: the actual relationship between the individual and the organization they work for helps determine whether that person is an employee entitled to ESA protections. Employers are prohibited from treating an employee covered by the Act as though they are not an employee.
Misclassification can result in enforcement action, including penalties or prosecution.
That is why simply inserting “independent contractor” into an agreement is not enough. Practical questions can reveal how the relationship actually operates. Who decides when the person works? How much control does the corporation have over how the work is performed? Does the worker provide services to other clients? Who provides the equipment? These details can become more significant than the heading at the top of the contract.
Condo Operations Can Blur the Lines
Condominiums can be particularly vulnerable to unclear arrangements because some workers become closely integrated into the building. Consider a superintendent initially hired as an independent contractor. Over time, the corporation might establish fixed working hours, determine daily tasks, provide the tools and equipment and expect that person to remain consistently available to the building.
Directors may still think of the person as a contractor because that was the original arrangement. Legally, however, worker classification depends on the circumstances. Ontario notes that employees potentially have ESA rights involving matters such as minimum wage, overtime, vacation, public holidays and termination. A classification problem can therefore become much more significant when the working relationship ends.
Classification Can Affect More Than Employment Standards
The distinction can also matter outside the ESA. Workplace safety, insurance, taxation and WSIB considerations can involve their own definitions and requirements. A worker may not necessarily be treated identically under every legal framework, which makes it risky for a board to assume one contract label resolves every question.

This is also why directors should be cautious about converting an existing employee into a contractor simply because the corporation wants a different administrative arrangement.
Changing how someone is paid or rewriting an agreement does not automatically change the substance of the relationship.
Look at the Arrangement Before Problems Develop
The independent contractor vs employee Ontario question is easier to address when the relationship is being established than after a dispute begins. New directors reviewing staffing arrangements should understand who performs the work, how much control the corporation exercises and how the arrangement functions in practice.
Professional property management can help boards maintain clearer operational boundaries and documentation. City Sites Property Management can support boards with the management of building operations and service relationships, while employment classification questions should be reviewed with appropriate legal, accounting or other professional advisers when required.
Listen to the podcast and learn more: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio





Comments