top of page

Is a Performance Bond Worth It for Your Condo's Next Big Project?

May 14, 2024
3 min read

There is no universal answer to whether a performance bond condo construction project should include is “worth it.” The decision depends on the project, contract, contractor and corporation’s risk tolerance. What directors should understand is what a performance bond does, what it does not do and why the decision should be made before the project is awarded rather than after trouble appears.


A Performance Bond Is Not Just Another Insurance Policy

The Canadian Construction Documents Committee publishes standard construction surety bond forms. CCDC 221 is its standard performance bond and is designed to guarantee the contractor’s performance of the underlying contract.


Suretyship involves three parties: the contractor, commonly called the principal; the owner, commonly called the obligee; and the surety providing the bond. This structure is different from simply purchasing a conventional insurance policy for the building. The bond responds according to its terms when the contractor defaults under the bonded construction contract.


For a condominium board, the practical purpose is risk management. If a contractor becomes unable or unwilling to complete its contractual obligations, a valid performance bond may provide a mechanism for the surety to respond, subject to the bond’s requirements.


Understand Which Bond the Board Is Discussing

“Bonding” is not one single product. CCDC currently publishes separate standard forms for a bid bond, performance bond, and labour and material payment bond.


A bid bond addresses the bidder’s commitment to enter into the formal contract and provide required contract security if its bid is accepted. A performance bond addresses performance of the construction contract. A labour and material payment bond deals with the contractor’s payment obligations for labour and materials.


Those protections solve different problems. Directors should therefore avoid approving “a bond” without understanding which bond is required, the amount of coverage and how it fits into the corporation’s broader construction contract.


Cost Needs to Be Compared With Exposure

An example is involving a roughly $2 million project and a performance-bond premium of about $40,000. That is useful as an anecdote about the kind of decision a board may face, but it should not be treated as a standard market price. Bond costs vary and should be confirmed for the actual project.


The better question is what financial exposure the corporation is trying to manage. On a large, technically complex project, contractor default can create substantial disruption. The corporation may face incomplete work, delays, site protection issues, additional consultant involvement and the challenge of finding another contractor.


The premium therefore needs to be considered alongside the consequences the corporation would face if performance failed, not simply as another percentage to remove from the project budget.


The Bond Must Work With the Contract

A performance bond should not be considered in isolation from the construction agreement. The definition of default, notice requirements and the steps needed to engage the surety matter. This is one reason professional coordination is important. The project consultant, construction lawyer, contractor and surety documentation should not be working from conflicting assumptions. The board should understand what the bond covers and what procedures the corporation must follow if a serious problem develops.


The CAO procurement guide recommends legal advice during critical stages of large and complex procurement projects. Decisions about contract security belong in that early planning process.


Risk Protection Is a Project-Specific Decision

A performance bond cannot guarantee that a construction project will be painless. It does not prevent change orders, eliminate disagreements, or replace careful contractor selection and competent project administration. What it can do is provide another form of contractual security against a particular risk: contractor non-performance. On a smaller or lower-risk project, the board and its advisers may reach one conclusion. On a multi-million-dollar restoration where contractor failure would expose the corporation to serious financial and operational consequences, the analysis may be very different. The board’s job is to understand that trade-off before deciding.


City Sites Property Management works with condominium boards on the management and coordination side of capital projects. Bringing management, consultants and legal advisers into the planning process early helps directors evaluate project risks before construction begins.


Comments


bottom of page