top of page

Why Cutting Service Contracts Often Costs Condo Boards More in the Long Run

May 30, 2024
3 min read
Suited person signs a document on a clipboard against a bright red background with a white city, tree and house icon.

The challenge with condo board cutting service costs is that a lower contract price and a lower total cost are not always the same thing. This article explored this tension through examples involving landscaping and other building services. The useful question for an experienced board is not simply, “How much can we cut?” It is, “What service are we prepared to change, and what happens elsewhere when we change it?”


Begin With the Service Level

Imagine a corporation spending $100,000 a year on landscaping. A director asks management to reduce the contract by 20 percent. That sounds like a clear cost-saving target, but the contractor cannot usually provide exactly the same labour, materials and frequency for substantially less money indefinitely.


Something has to change. Perhaps seasonal flowers are reduced, garden visits become less frequent or certain maintenance tasks move outside the contract. Those may all be reasonable choices if the community accepts the resulting service level. Problems arise when the board reduces the budget but residents continue expecting the previous level of service.


The CAO Guide on Procuring Goods and Services recommends documenting purchasing needs and developing a clear scope of work. That process is equally useful when reducing a service because it forces the board to identify what is actually being removed. 


Sometimes the Better Saving Comes From Redesign

Another example is of residents becoming involved with gardening. Community participation can sometimes reduce selected landscaping needs while giving interested residents a stronger connection to the property. Another building might replace labour-intensive planting areas with a design requiring less recurring maintenance.


These approaches differ from simply demanding that the existing contractor charge less. They change the underlying service model.


A board could similarly examine cleaning frequencies in little-used rooms, review staffing patterns with a security provider or assess maintenance schedules with qualified professionals. The objective is to determine what the building actually needs rather than applying the same percentage reduction to every contract.


Not every service should be redesigned, and some maintenance should not be deferred merely because the immediate budget looks better. Technical and safety requirements need to remain central to the decision.


Deferred Work Can Move the Cost Instead of Removing It

Preventive maintenance is particularly vulnerable during cost-cutting discussions because its value is often invisible. A system that is inspected and maintained properly may simply continue working, which makes the expense easy to question.


The risk is that eliminating appropriate maintenance does not necessarily eliminate the underlying need. It may move the expense into emergency repairs, equipment deterioration or earlier replacement.


The Condominium Authority of Ontario’s reserve fund guidance explains the importance of planning for major repairs and replacements of common elements and assets. Although routine operating maintenance and reserve expenditures serve different purposes, they are connected by the physical condition of the same building. Saving money in one budget line should not be evaluated without considering what it may do to the asset over time.


Resident Expectations Are Part of the Equation

A board also governs a community (not only a balance sheet). Reducing concierge hours, cleaning frequency or landscaping standards changes what residents experience. That does not mean services can never be reduced. It means directors should communicate the trade-off clearly. If owners strongly support lower operating costs, they should understand what level of service those savings may require.


This compared to choosing between different levels of vehicle. The exact analogy matters less than the underlying point: a corporation cannot continually demand premium service while budgeting for a substantially different service level.


Cut Waste, Not Understanding

Good boards should challenge costs. They should ask vendors difficult questions, test the market, examine scopes and look for more efficient ways to operate. None of that requires accepting every existing contract or every proposed increase.


The mistake is treating a lower invoice as proof of a better financial decision.


Before reducing a service contract, directors should identify what will change, what responsibilities remain, what residents will notice and whether the saving creates costs somewhere else. A thoughtful reduction can be good management. An unexplained reduction that simply moves the problem to next year is not.


City Sites Property Management works with condominium boards on budgeting, vendor management and building operations. Reviewing service levels alongside costs can help boards find efficiencies without losing sight of the property those services are meant to protect.


bottom of page