Managing a Unionized Security or Cleaning Contract: What Boards Need to Know

Understanding managing unionized condo security contract issues does not mean the board should become the employer’s labour-relations department. In many contracted-service arrangements, the guards or cleaners are employees of the service provider rather than the condominium corporation. Directors still need to understand that decisions about the vendor can interact with rights and obligations that exist at the worksite.
Start With the Collective Bargaining Context
A collective agreement governs the relationship between a unionized employer and the bargaining unit covered by the agreement. It can address wages, scheduling, seniority, benefits, discipline, grievance procedures and many other employment matters.
A condominium board should not assume that every operational request can simply be imposed through the contractor. If the board wants different staffing arrangements, schedules or duties, the service provider may need to consider its obligations under the collective agreement.
This is where good vendor management matters. The board can define the service outcome it requires, while the contractor addresses its responsibilities as employer. When an issue has labour-law implications, the corporation and provider may need appropriate professional advice rather than improvising a solution at a board meeting.
Changing Companies May Not Erase Bargaining Rights
The issue becomes particularly important when the board wants to replace the provider. Section 69.1 of Ontario’s Labour Relations Act, 1995 contains specific successor-rights provisions for building services. The section expressly includes building cleaning, food and security services.
These provisions were added through Ontario’s Fair Workplaces, Better Jobs Act, 2017. Their existence means a board should not assume that changing the contractor automatically eliminates the labour-relations framework associated with services at the property.
The exact consequences depend on the circumstances, which makes early legal review valuable when a unionized contract is approaching procurement or termination.
Employment Standards Also Matter
Union status is not the only consideration. Part XIX of Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 establishes special rules when one building service provider replaces another.
Ontario’s building services provider guide identifies cleaning and security among the services covered. The legislation can place termination and severance obligations on the new provider for eligible employees of the replaced provider whom it does not employ, subject to statutory rules and exceptions. These provisions can affect the economics of a bid. A prospective contractor may need information about the existing workforce to understand potential obligations before committing to a price.
Grievances Are Part of a Process
The podcast also discussed grievances and arbitration. Those words can sound alarming to directors unfamiliar with unionized environments, but a grievance is fundamentally a mechanism for addressing disputes about the collective agreement.
The important point for a board is not to treat every grievance as evidence that the vendor relationship has failed. Management should understand the issue, obtain information from the service provider and determine what effect, if any, it has on service delivery or the corporation’s contractual rights.
If the dispute directly affects the corporation or a contemplated vendor change, labour counsel may need to become involved. The board should avoid making assumptions about the meaning of a collective-agreement provision based solely on informal explanations.
Manage the Service, Respect the Legal Structure
A condominium corporation can still expect strong security or cleaning performance at a unionized property. Unionization does not remove the contractor’s obligation to deliver the service promised in its agreement with the corporation.
It does mean that the route to achieving a change may require more planning. Directors should understand the service contract, know when a collective agreement may be relevant and recognize that a provider change can trigger statutory considerations beyond ordinary procurement.
City Sites Property Management works with condominium boards on vendor coordination and building operations. Where union, employment or successor-rights questions arise, coordinated management and qualified Ontario labour counsel can help the board address the operational and legal issues in their proper lanes.





Comments