What Happens When a Board Waits Too Long: Lessons from a $3-5 Million Garage Repair

Garage deterioration can remain manageable for years, which is part of what makes deferral tempting. A leak may inconvenience a few parking spaces, a membrane patch may fail slowly and damaged concrete may not immediately affect how residents use the building. The danger with condo garage deferred maintenance risk is that the board can gradually lose the option of making small, controlled repairs.
Eventually, the building may be dealing with a much larger technical problem and a funding plan that has not caught up.
A Project That Had Few Easy Choices Left
A garage can reach a point where localized repairs are no longer enough to address the extent of deterioration. The corporation may face a larger repair program, limited reserve funds and fewer practical options for keeping the work affordable and manageable.
The concern is not simply the cost of concrete repairs. If deterioration affects structural elements, waterproofing systems or other critical components, the board may need to address safety concerns, obtain additional professional advice and plan work around resident access. These requirements can make the project more difficult to organize and increase the financial pressure on the corporation.
Most garage repairs do not reach this point, but boards should understand that structural recommendations can move beyond aesthetics and budgeting when an engineer identifies a genuine safety issue.
Reserve Fund Balance Alone Does Not Tell the Whole Story
Ontario corporations must maintain reserve funds for major repairs and replacements, but the CAO specifically cautions that a large or small balance by itself does not establish whether the fund is healthy. The more important question is whether enough money will be available when major projects become due. This distinction matters because a balance that looks comfortable can become inadequate when several expensive components reach the end of their service life together.
Directors also have a statutory standard of care. Section 37 of Ontario’s Condominium Act, 1998 requires directors to act honestly and in good faith and exercise the care, diligence and skill of a reasonably prudent person in comparable circumstances; it also recognizes good-faith reliance on appropriate professional reports and opinions. A serious engineering recommendation should therefore be evaluated carefully rather than repeatedly pushed forward simply because the budget is uncomfortable.
The lesson from this condo garage deferred maintenance risk example is not that every garage needs immediate restoration. It is that boards should preserve their choices while they still have them.
Proactive Oversight Protects Community Value and Solvency
Boards should give appropriate priority to garage conditions identified by qualified professionals, especially where safety or ongoing deterioration is involved. Acting on current engineering information can help the corporation manage structural, financial and liability risks before conditions become more difficult or expensive to address.
At City Sites Property Management, our property management experts help condominium boards evaluate engineering reports, manage reserve fund strategies, and oversee complex capital restoration projects. Contact the experienced team at City Sites Property Management today to learn how our tailored governance support can help your board maintain safe, compliant, and fiscally resilient infrastructure.





Comments