top of page

Should Your Board Defer a Reserve Fund Project? What Directors Need to Consider

May 26, 2025
2 min read
Two men in an office study wall charts, one pointing while the other thinks; pink overlay with a city-and-house icon at bottom.

A reserve fund study shows that the roof is scheduled for replacement this year, but an inspection finds that it remains in good condition. Does the corporation have to replace it simply because the study says so? Not necessarily.


A decision to defer a reserve fund project can be responsible when it is supported by current information, but postponing work simply to avoid a difficult financial decision is something very different.


The Study Provides a Schedule, Not an Expiry Date

Reserve fund studies use estimated remaining life to build a long-term funding plan. Actual components do not always fail according to those estimates. A roof projected for replacement after 20 years may still be performing well at year 20, while another component could deteriorate earlier than expected.


This distinction is important when reviewing reserve fund planning. The projected replacement year should prompt the corporation to examine the component rather than automatically authorize the project or automatically postpone it. A current condition assessment can help directors understand whether delaying the work is technically reasonable.


The board should also document why the project moved. Future directors and reserve fund professionals need to know that the change resulted from evidence rather than an unexplained budget decision.


Deferred Money Is Not Suddenly Surplus Money

Another common mistake is assuming that postponing a project frees the allocated reserve money for something unrelated. It does not.


Ontario’s Condominium Act, 1998 requires reserve funds to be maintained for major repair and replacement of common elements and corporate assets. The corporation’s reserve fund study looks across decades of expected expenditures, not simply one project at a time.


If a $500,000 project moves two years into the future, the underlying liability has not disappeared. The corporation still owns the component and may still need to spend the money later.


Deferral Should Be Based on Building Needs

There is a meaningful difference between extending the life of a component because professional evidence supports doing so and repeatedly pushing projects forward because the board wants to keep common expenses low.


Directors should ask what evidence supports the deferral, what maintenance will be required in the meantime and what could happen if the component deteriorates unexpectedly. They should also consider how moving the project changes the reserve fund cash flow.


Where the change is significant, discussing it with the reserve fund study provider can help the board understand its effect on future balances and contributions.


Good Timing Is Part of Good Governance

A decision to defer a reserve fund project should not automatically be viewed as a warning sign. Extending the useful life of an asset can be financially responsible when the physical condition supports it.


The important part is why the project is moving. Directors should be able to connect the decision to current building information, professional advice and the corporation’s long-term financial plan. Deferring work because the building does not need it yet is very different from deferring work because the board does not want to deal with the cost.


Listen to the podcast and learn more: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio 

Comments


bottom of page